From the 2026 budget audit
Why does every Hungarian wage-earner pay a stipend to Academy members?
An academician's honorarium is a recurring public stipend for membership in a self-selecting learned society — one that comparable academies abroad fund from endowments and subscriptions.
Roughly 2,300 Ft per taxpayer per year — 9,469.9 million Ft total, the bulk going to personnel and member honoraria in a private learned society.
What you see — and what you don't
The seen: several hundred senior scholars receiving a statutory stipend on top of their university or institute salary. The unseen: every wage-earner whose income tax and social contribution funds a supplement to colleagues whose primary livelihood is already secured elsewhere.
Objection
"But the Academy honours Hungary's finest scientists — surely they deserve recognition?"
Answer
Recognition is not the question. Comparable learned societies — the Royal Society, national academies across the continent — fund their secretariats and member honours from endowment, membership, and philanthropy. A five-year transition invites the MTA to stand up the same arrangement, while tapering rather than cutting honoraria already being drawn.
Share if you think a learned society's member stipends should be funded by its members, not by every taxpayer.
The analyst's verdict
MTA Secretariat Administration and Honoraria
Rationale
This line funds the administration of the Academy as a learned society and the *tiszteletdíjak* — the honoraria paid to academicians. The personnel and honoraria components dominate: 8,081.9 millió Ft of personnel cost against 454.3 millió Ft of operating expense means this is overwhelmingly a payroll-and-stipend line. An academician's honorarium is a recurring, statutorily defined cash payment to an elected member of a self-selecting body. Described without euphemism, it is a public stipend for the status of membership in a private learned society. The society's governing function — electing members, organising sections, conferring its own honours — is the archetypal voluntary association: as noted above, comparable learned societies in the Anglo-American tradition operate on endowment and membership income. The MTA could plausibly fund its secretariat and a reduced honorarium pool the same way; what tax financing buys here is not the society's existence but the particular scale and the particular insulation of the honorarium from any market or donor test of what the membership status is worth. The honorarium is not a research grant — it does not buy a unit of research output and cannot be calculated against one; it is a transfer whose level is set administratively. A five-year phase-out reduces the secretariat to a defensibly small statutory core (the Academy is named in the Fundamental Law, and a minimal secretariat administering elections and the public-law functions of a chartered body has a thin but real Keep claim) while the honorarium pool is wound down and the membership is invited to fund member stipends from subscription and endowment income, as comparable academies abroad do.
Transition mechanism
Over five years, separate the line into two streams. The statutory-core stream — the minimal administration of a body named in the Fundamental Law — is retained at a small residual (on the order of 1,500-2,000 millió Ft, sufficient for election administration, statutory reporting, and the public-law duties). The honorarium pool and the discretionary secretariat overhead are reduced by roughly one-fifth of the original each year. Current academicians are the protected party: honoraria already being drawn are tapered rather than cut, and the Academy is given the five-year window to stand up a member-funded stipend arrangement and a development (fundraising) capacity. The 79.9 millió Ft capital line is a routine investment item; it falls to zero in year one with the broader felhalmozási reductions, as no contractual counterparty's rights depend on it.
Affected groups
The roughly several hundred ordinary and corresponding members of the Academy who draw honoraria, and the secretariat staff. Honorarium recipients are, by the nature of Academy membership, established senior scholars — most hold or held salaried university or institute positions; the honorarium is a supplement, not a primary livelihood, which is why a taper rather than a bridge bond is the appropriate protection. Secretariat staff on permanent contracts whose roles fall outside the retained statutory core are addressed through the personnel reduction embedded in the five-year glide.
Sources
- 2019. évi LXVIII. törvény a kutatás, fejlesztés és innovációs rendszer intézményrendszerének és finanszírozásának átalakításáról · Magyar Közlöny / mkogy.jogtar.hu (2019)
Free Society Institute
Support independent analysis
Our research is free, open, and unsponsored. If you find it valuable, help us keep it that way.