From the 2026 budget audit
The state as venture capitalist — picking startups with your taxes
7 billion forints a year flows into state-managed capital funds that allocate tax money as venture equity, alongside private investors who can already do this without a state co-investor.
Roughly 1,670 Ft per taxpayer per year — 6.975 billion Ft committed to venture funds where the officials investing do not own the capital they place at risk.
What you see — and what you don't
The seen: state capital funds backing Hungarian companies, sometimes alongside private investors. The unseen: the private venture fund bidding on the same deals at a disadvantage because the state co-investor draws on involuntary tax finance and faces no personal loss if the bet fails — and the taxpayer whose money funds the equity without any of a shareholder's rights or returns.
Objection
"State venture capital fills gaps private investors won't touch — it backs the riskier, more innovative companies."
Answer
Where private investors co-invest alongside the state fund — as they do here, since the Nemzeti Tőkeholding model requires a minimum 30% private co-investment — the market has already validated the deal. The state tranche is crowding into a transaction private capital was willing to fund. Where private capital declined, the state fund is, by revealed preference, funding the projects the market judged not worth the risk. Hungary already has 39 active private venture and private-equity funds. The 4-year phase-out ends new state commitments while honouring existing fund positions to term.
Share if you think venture capital decisions should be made by people whose own money is at stake.
The analyst's verdict
Expenditures relating to ownership rights over capital funds
Rationale
This line, together with the Nemzeti Tőkeholding line below, funds the state acting as a venture-capital and private-equity investor through capital funds (tőkealapok). The Nemzeti Tőkeholding group was created in January 2023 to consolidate the state's partly or wholly state-backed capital funds under one roof.[^7] The state placing equity into venture and growth-capital funds is a clear instance of the calculation problem in the domain where it bites hardest. Venture investing is the business of allocating scarce capital across competing, uncertain projects on the basis of judgements about future returns — judgements that, in a market, are disciplined by the investor's own capital being at risk and by the price signals of competing private bids. A state capital fund allocating tax-sourced money faces neither discipline directly: the officials selecting the investments do not own the capital, and the returns (or losses) accrue to the budget rather than to them. Where the state fund crowds into deals private venture capital would also fund, it displaces private investors without adding capital to the economy; where it funds deals private capital declined, it is, by revealed preference, funding the projects the market judged not worth the risk. A private venture-capital and private-equity market operates in Hungary — Invest Europe data for 2022 recorded 39 active funds and approximately €420 million in new investment in Hungarian portfolio companies[^9] — and the case for an involuntary, tax-financed parallel allocator alongside it is weak.
Transition mechanism
A 4-year linear phase-out. Existing fund commitments — capital already committed to portfolio companies — are honoured to term; venture commitments are multi-year and cannot be unwound without destroying value. New state capital commitments end. As existing fund positions mature or are exited, the capital returns to the Treasury rather than being recycled into new state-fund commitments. Year 1 saves 1,743.75 millió Ft.
Affected groups
Portfolio companies holding existing state-fund commitments are protected by the run-off to term; private venture and growth-capital investors benefit from the removal of a tax-subsidised co-investor competing for the same deals.
Sources
- Jön a Nemzeti Tőkeholding! Egy kézbe vonja össze a tőkealapjait az állam · Portfolio.hu (2022)
Free Society Institute
Support independent analysis
Our research is free, open, and unsponsored. If you find it valuable, help us keep it that way.