A 2026-os költségvetés-elemzésből
A state company promoting cycling holidays — paid for by everyone, including those who never cycle.
Tourism promotion is a commercial activity. The businesses that profit from active tourists — hotels, guides, equipment hire — are the parties who should fund the marketing.
Roughly 466 Ft per taxpayer per year — 1,897 millió Ft to a state nonprofit that coordinates and promotes eco-tourism without facing the market test that would tell it whether its activities are worth the cost.
Amit látsz — és amit nem
The seen: the tourism company's staff and the active-tourism promotional work they carry out. The unseen: every wage-earner whose tax funds marketing for tourism operators — private businesses that earn revenue from voluntary customers — without those businesses having to pass a consumer test for the promotional spending they benefit from.
Ellenvetés
"Active tourism creates jobs across rural Hungary and generates tax revenue — a small state investment in promotion pays back many times over."
Válasz
If the payback is real, the businesses that capture it will fund the promotion voluntarily — tourism boards funded by member levies, destination-marketing organisations funded by the operators they serve. The arrangement that funds the promotion through general taxation asks the worker who never takes a cycling holiday to subsidise the marketing of the businesses that serve those who do. The company's employees are protected by a two-year severance-with-overlap; what ends is the ministerial transfer, not the tourism sector.
Share if you think tourism promotion should be funded by the tourism industry, not every taxpayer.
Az elemző értékelése
Aktív- és Ökoturisztikai Fejlesztési Központ Nonprofit Korlátolt Felelősségű Társaság
Az elemző indoklása jelenleg angol nyelven elérhető; magyar fordítás folyamatban.
Indoklás
The Aktív- és Ökoturisztikai Fejlesztési Központ is a state-owned nonprofit company whose mandate is to coordinate, promote, and develop active- and eco-tourism — walking, cycling, water, equine, and nature-tourism infrastructure and programmes.[^5] Tourism promotion and tourism-infrastructure development are commercial activities. The operators who benefit from active-tourism visitors — accommodation, guiding, equipment rental, hospitality — are private businesses that earn revenue from voluntary customers, and the test of whether a piece of tourism infrastructure or a promotional campaign is worth its cost is whether the businesses it serves will fund it. A state company carrying out this activity faces no such test: its survival depends on the ministry transfer, not on a consumer plebiscite, so the question "is it efficient" cannot be answered from the data the arrangement generates — efficiency in tourism development is the output of the market test, and the market test has been replaced by an appropriation. The activity belongs in the private and voluntary sector — tourism boards funded by the businesses they serve, destination-marketing organisations funded by member levies, private operators investing in their own infrastructure. It is classified as a Phase-Out rather than an Immediate Cut because the protected party is the company's employees, who hold employment contracts. The operating allocation of 1,832.1 millió Ft funds both payroll and non-payroll programme costs; the chapter table does not break the company's payroll out separately. A state nonprofit company of this kind typically runs payroll at roughly a third of its operating budget — taken here as an estimated payroll component of approximately 610 millió Ft pending confirmation against the company's published accounts before the schedule is finalised. The two-year horizon reflects a small organisation whose staff have transferable skills in marketing, project management, and tourism.
Átállási mechanizmus
Severance-with-overlap over 24 months for the payroll component, with the non-payroll programme and capital spending cut in the first budget cycle. The company's marketing, coordination, and project-management staff have transferable skills; the re-employment path is into private tourism businesses, destination-marketing organisations, or the wider marketing sector. In-flight infrastructure commitments run to contractual completion. Where active-tourism infrastructure remains genuinely wanted, the businesses and municipalities that benefit from it are the parties who should fund it. The payroll-share estimate is provisional; the schedule should be re-derived once the company's audited accounts confirm the personnel subset.
Érintett csoportok
The company's employees, protected by 24 months of severance-with-overlap; private tourism operators who currently benefit from state-funded coordination and promotion, who would thereafter fund destination marketing through the voluntary member-levy model used by tourism boards internationally.
Források
- Megalakult az Aktív és Ökoturisztikai Fejlesztési Központ · Országos Erdészeti Egyesület (oee.hu) (2019)
Szabad Társadalom Intézet
Támogasd a független elemzéseket
Kutatásunk ingyenes, nyílt és nem szponzorált. Ha hasznosnak találod, segíts fenntartani.