A 2026-os költségvetés-elemzésből
A voluntary citizen guard — funded by the state. That is a contradiction.
1.67 billion forints flows to the National Civil Guard Association, converting a voluntary movement into a body with professional dependence on the state budget.
About 417 Ft per taxpayer per year — 1.67 billion Ft total — to fund the federation of a voluntary movement, giving it a professional interest in maintaining its budget line.
Amit látsz — és amit nem
The seen: a national federation with a guaranteed state income and a professional staff funded from general taxation. The unseen: the volunteers across Hungary who patrol and assist communities — their voluntary activity does not depend on the federation's state grant, and will continue after it ends.
Ellenvetés
"The Civil Guard provides community safety that neither the state nor private citizens can replace — without funding it collapses."
Válasz
The volunteers' activity is genuine civil society and continues with or without the federation's state grant. The phase-out applies to the national federation's state subsidy, not to the local volunteer groups. A voluntary movement that depends on the state for its professional apparatus has already partially ceased to be voluntary. Three years gives the federation time to rebuild on membership fees and voluntary donations.
Share if you think voluntary citizen action should be funded by volunteers, not by the budget.
Az elemző értékelése
Országos Polgárőr Szövetség
Az elemző indoklása jelenleg angol nyelven elérhető; magyar fordítás folyamatban.
Indoklás
The Polgárőrség is a voluntary citizen civil-guard movement. The voluntary, self-organising character of citizen guarding is genuine voluntary society; the objection is to financing it from general taxation, which converts a voluntary association into a state-funded body and gives its national federation a professional dependence on the budget line.
Átállási mechanizmus
A three-year phase-out (556 millió Ft per year) protects the federation's planned commitments while it rebuilds a voluntary-funding base; the volunteers' activity does not depend on the federation's state grant.
Érintett csoportok
The National Civil Guard Association federation and its professional staff, who must rebuild on voluntary funding; the civil-guard volunteers, whose activity continues independently of the federation's state grant.
Szabad Társadalom Intézet
Támogasd a független elemzéseket
Kutatásunk ingyenes, nyílt és nem szponzorált. Ha hasznosnak találod, segíts fenntartani.